allworth-financial-logo-color
    • Wealth Management
      • Financial Planning
      • Investment Management
      • Tax Planning
      • Estate Planning
      • Insurance Services
    • 401(k) For Employers
    • For Airline Employees
    • Our Approach
    • Why People Work With Us
    • Office Locations
    • FAQs
    • Our Fees
    • Our Story
    • Advisors
    • Our Leadership
    • Advisory Firm Partnerships
    • Allworth Kids
    • Webinars & Events
    • Podcasts
    • Financial Planning
    • Investment Management
    • Tax Planning
Meet With Us
  • Locations
  • Login
  • Contact

Have a pension? You might have a huge decision to make

  • Share this post

Allworth Co-CEO Scott Hanson explains why the rise in interest rates is encouraging some pension recipients to move up their retirements.

  

Will you be choosing the lump-sum payout, or a monthly pension payment?

If you’re employed by the healthcare, manufacturing, automobile, or utility sectors (or, for that matter, any industry that offers a traditional pension), when it comes to your retirement, you’ve probably heard the above question before.

To be sure, because everyone’s situation is unique, ultimately, the choice between a lump-sum payout option and a fixed-monthly payment is a decision that should be analyzed and reviewed with a fiduciary advisor who can take into consideration factors such as your overall financial situation, life expectancy, investment options, and savings levels, along with the needs of your family, just to name a few.

The amount of a lump-sum payout, or a monthly payment amount, are both calculated based on factors such as salary history, years of service, your age, the specifics of your plan, and, as I’ll soon cover, current interest rates.

So, when it comes to the decision between a lump sum or ongoing monthly payments, which option do workers typically prefer?

The fact is, that while some people are more comfortable with the security of a predictable monthly payment, according to The Wall Street Journal, depending on company and industry, at least 50%, and perhaps as high as 80% of all workers, choose the lump-sum payout over the prospect of a pre-determined monthly pension. 1

Some of the reasons workers prefer lump-sum payouts include that, not only do most people believe that with compounding interest, they can achieve a higher rate of return (and therefore, more money overall) by investing the money themselves, or with an advisor, but there are also more available options for passing the money along to their non-spousal heirs. Also, as a bird in the hand is still worth two in the bush, the lump sum amount is cash in hand, as opposed to a monthly payment amount, which may not be fully guaranteed. (For example, even though the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation exists to protect consumer pensions, I know of people who have received as little as 1/3 of their promised monthly payout after the employer declared bankruptcy.)  

While there are lots of things to consider, one thing seems clear: For some workers – and with only two months left in 2022 – the answer to the “Should I take a lump-sum payout?” question may never again be as clear as it is right now.

That’s because many lump-sum pension payouts are going to take a substantial hit in 2023.

So, why the decline?

Employers use various calculations to determine future lump sum payout amounts, but chief among them (and little understood) are periodically calculated interest rates. That’s because, as the thinking goes, if interest rates are high, employees will need smaller lump sum payouts to make the same amount of money in the future as they would in a low interest rate environment.  

Everyone knows that interest rates have skyrocketed in 2022. And because there is a calendar year-over-year-interest-rate-lag in determining lump sum payouts, what happens with interest rates this year substantially impacts the amounts of payouts in the future.

After years of low interest rates, virtually everyone now clearly understands how they impact what we pay for the money we borrow. What fewer people realize, however, is that these same interest rates have just as big of an impact on future lump-sum payouts.

How much?

2022’s higher interest rates could lower 2023’s lump-sum payout amounts by as much as 30%.

Depending on the variables outlined above (salary, years of service, etc.), if you can retire in 2022, but you wait until 2023, you could see a hit to your lump-sum payment amount by as much as $100,000, $250,000, or even $300,000. (One person I researched, who would receive a 20% reduction to her lump sum, would lose $320,000 if she waited until 2023 to retire.) 2

These numbers are obviously substantial and bear investigating.

A few things: First, this does not mean you should automatically run out and file for retirement. On the contrary, I hope this serves as a wake-up call to conduct your due diligence so you can determine the best option for your personal situation. Also, it’s important to note that not all types of pensions are affected by this calculation of interest rates. (For instance, cash-balance pensions are not impacted.)  

Next, it’s essential to understand that your employer does not control interest rates; the government does. Further, for some companies, the calculated interest rate portion of the equation that is used to lock in lump-sum payouts for next year were only just published in September, so if the buzz in your industry around moving up 2023’s retirements to this year (2022) is only just beginning to gain steam, that may help explain why.  

While there are certainly more things to consider than interest rates, such as whether you’re emotionally ready to retire, the amount of other savings you have, your debt, your age, and your short- and long-term life and financial goals, a wise man once said, “The most successful person in life is the person who has the most accurate information.”

Simply, should any of the above apply to you, or even to a coworker or friend, after 30 years of working with clients to help maximize their pensions, and because this year is unlike any other that I can remember, with just under two months left in 2022, you owe it to yourself to do absolutely everything you can to make certain you have a complete grasp of all of your options.   

 

1 Should You Retire Early to Get a Larger Lump Sum on Your Pension? - WSJ

2 Retirees' lump sum pension payouts will be hit hard by interest rates (freep.com)

 

Give yourself an advantage. Sign up to receive monthly insights from our Chief Investment Officer, and be the first to know about upcoming educational webinars. You'll also get instant access to our retirement planning checklist.

Related Articles
See more articles
December 02, 2022 The ABCs of Roth IRAs

Allworth Co-CEO Scott Hanson breaks down the basics of Roth IRAs and Roth conversions. You hear a great deal about Roth IRAs and Roth conversions, …

Read Now
September 09, 2022 Do you know these 3 things about your 401(k)?

Allworth Co-CEO Scott Hanson shares a few key reminders about 401(k)s. Each year, National 401(k) Day lands on the first Friday after Labor Day. It’s …

Read Now
November 05, 2021 Maxed out your 401(k)? Where to save next

Allworth Co-CEO Scott Hanson shares three savings alternatives for anyone who's already met the 2021 401(k) contribution limit. Even good savers have …

Read Now
Allworth Financial logo
Talk with an Advisor Contact us
  • Services
    • Wealth Management
    • 401(k) For Employers
    • For Airline Employees
  • Working With Us
    • Why People Work With Us
    • Office Locations
    • FAQs
    • Our Fees
    • Client Login
  • About Us
    • Advisors
    • Our Leadership
    • Advisory Firm Partnerships
    • Allworth Kids
    • Careers
    • Form CRS
  • Insights
    • Workshops & Events
    • Podcasts
    • Financial Planning
    • Investment Management
    • Tax Planning

Newsletter

Subscribe to receive monthly insights from our Chief Investment Officer, and be the first to know about upcoming educational webinars.

©1993-2025 Allworth Financial. All rights reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclosures
  • Cookie Preferences
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

Advisory services offered through Allworth Financial, a Registered Investment Advisor

Securities offered through AW Securities, a Registered Broker/Dealer, member FINRA/SIPC. Check the background of this firm on FINRA's BrokerCheck.

HMRN Insurance Agency, LLC license #0D34087

Rankings and/or recognition by unaffiliated rating services and/or publications should not be construed by a client or prospective client as a guarantee that he/she will experience a certain level of results if Allworth is engaged, or continues to be engaged, to provide investment advisory services.  Rankings should not be considered an endorsement of the advisor by any client nor are they representative of any one client’s evaluation or experience. Rankings published by magazines, and others, generally base their selections exclusively on information prepared and/or submitted by the recognized advisor.  Therefore, those who did not submit an application for consideration were excluded and may be equally qualified.

1.  Barron’s Top 100 RIA Firms: Barron’s ranking of independent advisory companies is based on assets managed by the firms, technology spending, staff diversity, succession planning and other metrics. Firms who wish to be ranked fill out a comprehensive survey about their practice. Allworth did not pay a fee to be considered for the ranking.  Allworth has received the following rankings in Barron’s Top 100 RIA Firms: #14 in 2024, #20 in 2023 and #31 in 2022. #23 in 2021, #27 in 2020.

2.  Retention Rate Source: Allworth Internal Data, FY 2022

3 & 9.  NBRI Circle of Excellence and Best in Class Ethics:  National Business Research Institute, Inc. (NBRI) is an independent research firm hired by Allworth to survey our customers. The survey contains eighteen (18) scaled and benchmarked questions covering a total of seven (7) topics, and a range of additional scaled, multiple choice, multiple select and open-ended question and is deployed biannually. NBRI compares responses across its company universe by industry and ranks the participating companies in each topic. The Circle of Excellence level is bestowed upon clients receiving a total company score at or above the 75th percentile of the NBRI ClearPath Benchmarking database.  Allworth’s 2023 results were compiled from 1,470 completed surveys, with results in the 92nd percentile. Allworth pays NBRI a fee to conduct the survey.

4.  As of 1/1/2025, Allworth Financial, an SEC registered investment adviser and AW Securities, a registered broker/dealer have approximately $26 billion in total assets under management and administration.

5.  Investment News Best Places to Work for Financial Advisors:  Investment News ranking of Best Places to Work for Financial Advisors is based on being a United States based Registered Investment Adviser with a minimum of 15 full or part-time employees working in the United States and having been in business for over a year.  Firms who meet Investment News’ criteria fill out an in-depth questionnaire and employees were asked to take part in a companywide survey.  Results of the questionnaire and employee surveys were analyzed by Investment News to determine recipients.  Allworth Financial did not pay a fee to be considered for the ranking.  Allworth Financial has received the ranking in 2020 and 2021.

6.  2021 Value of an Advisor Study / Russel Investments

7.  RIA Channel Top 50 Wealth Managers by Growth in Assets:  RIA Channel’s ranking of the Top 50 Wealth Managers by Growth in Assets is based on being an active Registered Investment Adviser with the Securities and Exchange Commission with no regulatory, criminal or administrative violations at the time of the ranking, provide wealth management services as their primary business and have a two year growth rate of 30% based on assets reported on Form ADV Part 1 at the time of ranking.  Allworth Financial did not pay a fee to be considered for the ranking.  Allworth Financial received the ranking in 2022.

8.  USA Today Best Financial Advisory Firms: USA Today’s ranking of Best Financial Advisory Firms was compiled from recommendations collected through an independent survey and a firm’s short and long-term AUM growth obtained from public sources. Allworth Financial did not participate in the survey, as self-recommendations are prohibited from consideration, and all surveyed individuals were selected at random. Allworth Financial did not pay a fee to be considered for the ranking. Allworth Financial received the ranking in 2024.

Tax services are provided by Allworth Tax Solutions, an affiliate of Allworth Financial. Allworth Financial does not provide tax preparation services or advice.

Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards Inc. owns the certification marks CFP®, CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™, CFP® (with plaque design) and CFP® (with flame design) in the U.S., which it awards to individuals who successfully complete CFP Board's initial and ongoing certification requirements.

Important Information

The information presented is for educational purposes only and is not intended to be a comprehensive analysis of the topics discussed. It should not be interpreted as personalized investment advice or relied upon as such.

Allworth Financial, LP (“Allworth”) makes no representations or warranties as to the accuracy, timeliness, suitability, completeness, or relevance of the information presented. While efforts are made to ensure the information’s accuracy, it is subject to change without notice. Allworth conducts a reasonable inquiry to determine that information provided by third party sources is reasonable, but cannot guarantee its accuracy or completeness. Opinions expressed are also subject to change without notice and should not be construed as investment advice.

The information is not intended to convey any implicit or explicit guarantee or sense of assurance that, if followed, any investment strategies referenced will produce a positive or desired outcome. All investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. There can be no assurance that any investment strategy or decision will achieve its intended objectives or result in a positive return. It is important to carefully consider your investment goals, risk tolerance, and seek professional advice before making any investment decisions.