Matthew Potter

Financial Advisor

Matthew Potter is a financial advisor in Allworth’s Indianapolis, Indiana, office with nearly a decade of financial services experience. By combining his natural curiosity for financial markets with a desire to build long-term relationships, he develops tailored investment strategies for his clients that align with their personal goals and objectives.

Prior to Allworth, Matthew served as a Vice President—Client Solutions for Sheaff Brock Investment Advisors, which merged with Allworth in 2025. He began his career journey as a high school math teacher, where he learned to break down complex topics into an easily understandable format for students, a skill he put to use in his next role as Derivatives Trading Manager at Charles Schwab. He then transitioned to Schwab Wealth Advisory where he worked as an Associate Wealth Advisor.

A graduate of Indiana Wesleyan University with a degree in Economics, Matthew also holds a master’s in teaching from Marian University. When not in the office, he coaches his young son’s baseball team, plays guitar, and enjoys the outdoors. You can also find Matthew in a local record shop or bookstore, or at any local sporting event or concert.

Talking about money isn’t always easy. But I’ve found that the more I’m willing to share about my own life, the more comfortable clients feel opening up. I’ll talk about coaching my son’s baseball team or playing music, and pretty soon we’re having a real conversation—not just about finances, but about what really matters. That’s how we get past “I just want to make money” and into the heart of what they’re really working toward: who the money is for, what experiences they want to have, and how they define peace of mind.

It’s also important to note that I don’t chase trends or try to squeeze every last drop of return from a portfolio. My goal is to build investment strategies that make sense for each of my clients, meaning they’re aligned with their goals, values, and comfort level. I often say, “Investing should never make you nervous or anxious.” If you’re ever worried about it, you’re doing it wrong.

I enjoy helping people think differently about money. It’s not the goal, it’s a tool. When used with intention, it can create the kind of life you truly want to live. That might mean feeling secure in retirement, creating meaningful experiences with family, or simply sleeping better at night knowing you’re on solid financial ground. I want every financial decision to feel purposeful—not overwhelming—and for clients to walk away with clarity, confidence, and a sense of control over their future.

Money is a tool—not a goal. If you use it wisely, it can help you achieve the life you want to live.

Latest Insights


The Emotional Side of Estate Planning: Preparing Your Family for the Future

Planning for your wealth's future involves more than just legal documents—it’s about creating a lasting legacy that your family understands and can …

Read more
The Myth of Market Timing: How Emotional Investing Can Lead to Poor Outcomes

Is your ‘gut’ in charge of making investing decisions for you? Here’s why that’s a bad strategy.

Read more
The Top 6 Tax Planning Mistakes High-Net-Worth Investors Make (And How to Avoid Them)

Explore some of the most common tax planning missteps high-net-worth investors face—and discover strategies for optimizing your wealth.

Read more