7 Things to Consider Before Buying a Second Home (Yes, Even If You Can Afford It)

There’s something undeniably charming about the moment you start thinking seriously about a second home. Maybe it happens after a perfect long weekend on the coast. Maybe you’ve found yourself scrolling listings “just to look.” Or maybe you’ve already picked out the porch swing where you plan to drink your morning coffee while gazing at the mountains.

For many high-net-worth households, a second home represents more than a getaway. It’s a lifestyle upgrade, a gathering place, a future retirement base, or a piece of the legacy they want to build. But even when affordability isn’t the barrier, strategy still matters.

Before you commit to a property that may very well become part of your family story, here are seven factors worth weighing carefully.

1. How the Home Fits into Your Overall Wealth Strategy

When your net worth puts you firmly in the “we can buy this comfortably” category, the calculation shifts. It’s no longer about affordability. Now it’s about congruence.

A vacation home becomes part of your wealth plan’s architecture, which means it interacts with everything else:

• Your liquidity profile
• The structure of your investment portfolio
• Your risk exposure
• Your long-term flexibility
• Your future tax picture

Real estate is a concentrated, non-diversified asset. That’s not inherently bad. After all, plenty of affluent families use real estate as a meaningful pillar of their strategy. But it does require intention and careful modeling to keep your financial ecosystem balanced.

2. The Opportunity-Cost of Tying Up Capital

Most high-net-worth buyers aren’t worried about the next property tax bill. What they are weighing is the strategic tradeoff of moving seven figures into an asset that’s illiquid, location-dependent, and emotionally sticky.

If that same capital were instead fueling portfolio growth, generating tax-efficient income, supporting philanthropic goals, or creating optionality for future opportunities, what might that mean for your long-term trajectory?

You’re not counting pennies. You’re evaluating potential.

3. How Often You'll Use It (Not Just Say You Will)

Here’s something that surprises even well-off families: the more someone idealizes a second home, the less they sometimes end up using it.

Real life gets crowded. Kids’ activities take over weekends, work travel pops up unexpectedly, weather disrupts plans, and the distance between home and second home can feel larger than it looks on paper. Even with ample resources, people often visit less frequently than they imagined.

Your realistic usage matters because it shapes everything from whether owning aligns with the lifestyle you want to whether you should preserve more liquidity or treat the property as a long-term hold versus a shorter chapter.

4. Whether Renting It Out Supports (Or Disrupts) the Life You Want

A lot of second-home owners picture renting out the property during weeks they’re not there. But for affluent buyers, it’s less about offsetting costs and more about whether renting limits your ability to use the home freely, whether you’re willing to take on the administrative overhead (even with a management company), and how rental activity shapes your tax picture.

It’s also worth considering who will be using the home when you’re not.

Even well-intentioned renters can treat a property differently than an owner would, and a less-than-ideal renter can introduce unexpected stress and costs at exactly the wrong time. For some families, that tradeoff feels manageable. For others, it turns what was meant to be a retreat into something that feels uncomfortably close to a part-time job.

When renting is part of the plan, that’s when the details start to matter:

• The IRS 14-day rule
• Passive vs. active income considerations
• Depreciation and future recapture
• Local short-term rental restrictions
• Wear-and-tear that may accelerate maintenance needs

Renting can be a smart, strategic move, but only when it complements how you actually want to use the home and the level of involvement you want in your day-to-day life.

5. The Subtle But Significant Impact on Retirement Planning

Even when your retirement is well on track, a second home can influence the long-term math in ways families don’t always expect:

• Cash-flow projections may shift
• Required investment returns can increase
• Liquidity assumptions might need to be revisited
• The timing of other large goals (gifting, travel, transitions) may change
• Your tax situation could evolve, especially with multi-state considerations

A well-constructed plan can easily absorb all of this, as long as it’s intentionally integrated.

6. Estate & Legacy Planning Considerations

Vacation homes tend to hold an emotional charge, which can be wonderful. And complicated. If you intend for the property to stay in the family, it’s worth exploring:

• Whether your children actually want it someday
• How shared use and shared expenses would work
• Whether a trust or LLC could simplify transitions
• Potential estate tax implications
• How the property fits into your charitable or legacy goals

A little clarity today protects a lot of harmony later.

7. Whether the Lifestyle Truly Matches the Commitment

A second home has a way of shaping your routines without you realizing it. It influences where you vacation, how you use long weekends, and how spontaneous you can be with travel.

For some families, that grounding is the point. They love returning to the same place and building traditions. For others, especially those who crave novelty or flexibility, a second home can eventually feel more limiting than freeing.

Before buying, it’s worth asking whether the property aligns with the life you genuinely want to build over the next decade, or whether it simply reflects a feeling you loved on vacation but might not want to commit to long-term.

Final Thoughts

A second home can be a beautiful addition to your life as a place to rest, recharge, and create memories that span generations. But it’s also a meaningful financial decision that benefits from clarity, modeling, and thoughtful planning.

If you’re ready to explore the idea more seriously, we invite you to talk with our team of in-house fiduciaries and wealth planning specialists. We can help you evaluate the tradeoffs, model the impact on your overall wealth plan, explore tax-efficient ownership structures, and confirm this purchase supports the life you’re building—not just the moment you’re dreaming about.

And if the numbers and the plan line up, then by all means, go ahead and fall in love with the porch swing.

The information presented is for educational purposes only and is not intended to be a comprehensive analysis of the topics discussed. It should not be interpreted as personalized investment advice or relied upon as such.

Allworth Financial, LP (“Allworth”) makes no representations or warranties as to the accuracy, timeliness, suitability, completeness, or relevance of the information presented. While efforts are made to ensure the information’s accuracy, it is subject to change without notice. Allworth conducts a reasonable inquiry to determine that information provided by third party sources is reasonable, but cannot guarantee its accuracy or completeness. Opinions expressed are also subject to change without notice and should not be construed as investment advice.

The information is not intended to convey any implicit or explicit guarantee or sense of assurance that, if followed, any investment strategies referenced will produce a positive or desired outcome. All investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. There can be no assurance that any investment strategy or decision will achieve its intended objectives or result in a positive return. It is important to carefully consider your investment goals, risk tolerance, and seek professional advice before making any investment decisions.